Handling Hurtful Comments About a Second Marriage
IMB Editorial Team · 21 November 2026 · about 3 min read
After a second marriage you may hear unkind remarks from relatives, neighbours or strangers. Staying calm does not mean accepting injustice or insult. Separate four things: which questions get a short answer, which gossip to stop, when to keep distance, and when to answer for your own faults. If you doubt the Sharia side of your own case, ask a qualified mufti.
Not all comments are alike
Society's words fall into four kinds.
- Curiosity: questions such as "How did it come about?" which you need not answer.
- Rumour: baseless talk that should be stopped from spreading.
- Real complaint: such as neglect of maintenance, deception or injustice, which deserves serious attention.
- Harassment: threats, stalking, leaking private details or pestering children.
For the first two, staying calm and brief is best. Do not wave away the third as "what people say". For the fourth, take legal help.
A one-sentence boundary
Fix one steady sentence in advance. For example: "This is a private family matter. We are looking at the necessary Sharia and legal questions with responsible people. Please do not comment about the wives or children." Repeat the same line, give no new details. The more you explain, the more material rumour has.
Islamic guidance
Surah Al-Hujurat (49:11) forbids ridicule, slander and offensive nicknames. Verse 12 tells believers to avoid much suspicion, spying and backbiting. That instruction is both for those who speak harshly about you and for you: answering unkind words with insult or revenge is best avoided. Sahih al-Bukhari 6114 calls controlling oneself in anger true strength. Remember this when replying online too, because a message written in anger cannot be recalled.
When the complaint may hold truth
If someone says the first wife is not getting maintenance, the second marriage was hidden, or someone is being treated unfairly, do not dismiss it as mere social talk. Following the consultation principle of Surah Ash-Shura (42:38), sit with a trusted mediator or elder and examine your own accounts and conduct. If there is a fault, admit it and put it right. That is not weakness but responsibility.
What to do if harassed
For threats, stalking, release of private information, pestering of children or false publicity:
- Save all messages, images and dates.
- Report through the platform's rules.
- Take a lawyer's advice if needed.
- In urgent danger, call 999.
- Inform children's teachers or a trusted guardian.
Answering with counter-insults weakens your own position. Keep the evidence and stay restrained.
Pressure inside the family
Often the hardest remarks come from your own family: parents, siblings or the first wife's relatives. Here it is better to speak directly, calmly and privately. Entering group arguments or explaining in front of everyone complicates matters. Keep a trusted elder as mediator.
Protecting your children and wives
Children may hear unkind remarks at school or in the neighbourhood. Speak with them in simple words so they are not ashamed or afraid. Also do not let the wives carry society's talk against each other. If there is warmth between the two wives, outside remarks lose much of their force.
Common mistakes
Answering every comment; posting explanations on social media; treating critics as enemies and avoiding everyone; and dismissing a genuine complaint as rumour.
When to ask a mufti or specialist
Ask a qualified mufti about the Sharia side of your second marriage, the duty of justice, or the limits of keeping ties with relatives. You can send a question through /ask-mufti. If stress mounts, speak with an experienced counsellor. If harassment becomes legal in nature, take a lawyer's help.
Frequently Asked Questions
Must I answer every unkind remark?
No; repeating one short boundary sentence is enough.
How do I tell rumour from a real complaint?
Specific claims of neglected maintenance, deception or injustice may be real, so examine them with a mediator.
What if there are threats or harassment?
Save the evidence, take legal help and call 999 in danger.
Is it right to reply online?
Better not in a moment of anger, since self-control is true strength (Sahih al-Bukhari 6114).
From the Blog
Have questions about Shariah-compliant marriage guidance?
Contact Us