Justice Between Wives: Impossible or Easy? A Balanced Reading of Quran 4:3 and 4:129
IMB Editorial Team · 21 November 2026 · about 8 min read
In discussions of plural marriage two opposite claims are heard. One group says, "Nobody can be just in our times." Another says, "Justice is not hard at all, and warning people is wrong." Both are oversimplifications. What the Quran and Sunnah indicate is this: justice is a real condition, binding wherever it is within a person's power (spending, time, housing, conduct); where something lies beyond human control, such as the inclination of the heart, perfect equality is not demanded, yet leaning wholly to one wife and neglecting the other is still forbidden. This is general education; for your own case, ask a mufti.
Two verses that must be read together
In Surah An-Nisa, verse 3, Allah says:
فَإِنْ خِفْتُمْ أَلَّا تَعْدِلُوا۟ فَوَٰحِدَةً
Meaning: "But if you fear that you will not be just, then one." (Surah An-Nisa 4:3)
And verse 129 says:
وَلَن تَسْتَطِيعُوٓا۟ أَن تَعْدِلُوا۟ بَيْنَ ٱلنِّسَآءِ وَلَوْ حَرَصْتُمْ ۖ فَلَا تَمِيلُوا۟ كُلَّ ٱلْمَيْلِ فَتَذَرُوهَا كَٱلْمُعَلَّقَةِ ۚ وَإِن تُصْلِحُوا۟ وَتَتَّقُوا۟ فَإِنَّ ٱللَّهَ كَانَ غَفُورًا رَّحِيمًا
Meaning: "You will never be able to be fully equal between wives, however much you desire. So do not incline completely and leave one as if suspended. And if you amend and are mindful of Allah, then Allah is Forgiving and Merciful." (Surah An-Nisa 4:129)
The first verse makes justice a condition of the marriage. The second acknowledges that people cannot keep total equality, yet forbids inclining wholly to one side. Reading them together, many commentators and jurists say that in matters where equality is within human ability, justice is obligatory, and in matters beyond it (such as the pull of the heart) it is excused. This is the general scholarly explanation; we have not checked the exact book and page ourselves, so confirm with a mufti.
Why "impossible" is wrong, and why "very easy" is incomplete
Whoever says "justice is impossible" has read half of verse 129. The verse speaks of the impossibility of complete equality, but in the same breath commands amendment and mindfulness of Allah. If justice were wholly impossible, the permission in verse 3 would be meaningless. On the other hand, whoever says "justice is simple, nothing to fear" is making light of the condition. Justice is not just paying equal sums; it includes time, conduct, attention, respect and responsibility toward children. In practice it takes daily awareness and self-restraint.
One more point: one person's ease at being fair does not guarantee the same for another. Some compare fairness among children, students or siblings. The comparison helps somewhat but is not complete, because marriage involves distinct rights such as maintenance, nights, emotional inclination and security. So it is wrong to claim either "easy" or "hard" as a one-sided slogan.
The warning of the Sunnah and the example of the Prophet
Sunan Abi Dawud (2133) reports from Abu Hurayrah (may Allah be pleased with him) that the Prophet (peace be upon him) said that a man who has two wives and inclines to one of them will come on the Day of Resurrection with one side hanging down. Al-Albani and Shu'ayb al-Arna'ut graded it sahih, while Zubair Ali Zai graded it weak. It is well known as a warning, but the difference over its chain should be known.
In the same book (2134) Aisha (may Allah be pleased with her) reports that the Prophet (peace be upon him) divided his time equally among his wives and said, "O Allah, this is my division in what I control; do not blame me for what You control and I do not." The grade of this report is also disputed (al-Albani weak; Zubair Ali Zai said the chain is sahih). So we mention it as a report of disputed grade and build no ruling on it; we only note that the practical model concerns visible things like dividing time.
The practical areas of justice: test yourself
The areas where scholars usually ask for equality are visible matters like these (not checked against the books; confirm with a mufti):
- Maintenance: food, clothing, medical care, necessary spending. This does not mean identical sums, but a fair arrangement for each wife's needs and standing.
- Housing: a safe, separate and dignified place for each wife.
- Time and nights: fixing a rotation and keeping to it.
- Conduct: speech, respect, treatment of each wife's children, not belittling a wife before others.
- Transparency: not hiding one wife's situation from the other in a way that destroys rights.
Ask yourself:
- Can my income cover fair expenses for both households without borrowing?
- Can I give each family the time it needs alongside work and worship?
- Am I alert to whether my mood or conduct shows favouritism?
- Am I equally honest with both wives?
- When a wife complains, am I willing to listen and correct myself?
If the honest answers are uncertain, remember the words "if you fear" in 4:3.
"Zina is worse, so a little unfairness is acceptable": how sound is this?
Some say many people are drifting into illicit relations, so it is wrong to deter them from marriage by stressing justice, since a slight shortfall in justice is lighter than zina. A few balancing points. First, easing the lawful path is commendable, and presenting the condition of justice as terrifying without reason is also wrong. Second, but one sin being greater does not make another sin lawful. Wronging a woman is a violation of a human being's right, and such rights must be settled, or answered for in the Hereafter. Third, when a woman, her children and her family bear the harm, their suffering is not made small by calling it a "lighter sin". Fourth, we know of no verified figure for how many people do what, so we do not use percentage claims. The safest course is to give the condition of justice its proper weight while not treating the lawful path as needlessly hard where real need and capacity exist.
Whom to learn from: experience and caution
Some say only those who have themselves married more than once can speak correctly. Experience is valuable but not the only measure. Knowledge of the Shari'ah and practical experience are both useful. Whether someone is married plurally or not is not how we judge the soundness of his words; judge by his reasoning, his evidence and his conduct. Declaring that "everyone is practising full justice" cannot be verified from outside. Consult several reliable scholars and, where appropriate, listen to the wives of the families concerned.
Signs that justice is breaking down
Injustice rarely arrives in one day; small neglects accumulate. Stop and correct yourself if you notice:
- You reply slowly to one wife's calls and quickly to the other's.
- "There is no money" for one house's needs while the other house is funded.
- You repeatedly arrive late or cancel on a wife's night and never make up for it.
- One household is prioritised for children's schooling, medical care or Eid shopping.
- You criticise one wife before the other, or stir quarrels between them.
- When a wife complains you grow angry or end the talk with "be patient."
The hadith's warning of one side "hanging down" matters for this reason: small favouritism piles up into great wrong.
The wives' perspective
Wives bear the most when justice fails. The first wife fears losing her place; the second fears being neglected. Their expectations are usually modest: respect, safety, the promised time and spending, and honest dealing. When a husband gives these, jealousy does not vanish, but conflict falls sharply. Wives, too, should raise complaints calmly and not let jealousy turn into harm.
Practical steps
- Make a written plan: monthly spending, rotation, housing. Tell both wives.
- Keep savings for the unexpected: illness, childbirth, job loss.
- If a night is missed, apologise and make it up.
- Do not compare the wives or criticise one before the other.
- Hold a regular, calm listening session, for example monthly.
- Seek a third party: a senior scholar or elder who hears both sides.
- If you cannot cope, stop. If justice cannot be kept, seek a scholar's advice promptly and do not take away anyone's rights.
Common misconceptions
- "Justice is impossible, so plural marriage is forbidden." A partial reading; 4:3 grants permission.
- "Justice is as easy as water." The condition is serious and the hadith warns of it.
- "Justice means exactly equal in everything." Perfect equality is not demanded where it is beyond ability.
- "Secrecy is fine; it does not affect justice." Secrecy often leads to rights being lost.
- "If one man is unjust, everyone is to blame." One person's wrong should not be placed on others; nor should a lawful ruling make everyone suspect.
When to ask a mufti
For the limits of justice, rotation or the division of spending, take your own case to a mufti. You can send a question through our "Ask the Muftis" page (/ask-mufti).
Frequently Asked Questions
Does 4:129 say justice is impossible, so plural marriage is forbidden?
It speaks of the impossibility of complete equality, yet in the same verse commands amendment and not inclining wholly; 4:3 grants permission. This is the general scholarly explanation; confirm with a mufti.
What does justice include?
A fair arrangement in visible matters such as maintenance, housing, time and conduct; perfect equality is not demanded in matters beyond ability such as the pull of the heart. Confirm with a mufti.
Which hadith warns about leaning to one wife?
Sunan Abi Dawud 2133; al-Albani and al-Arna'ut graded it sahih, Zubair Ali Zai weak. Take it as a warning, knowing the difference.
What if someone is not being just?
Apologise promptly, make amends and seek a scholar's advice. Wives should raise complaints calmly and, if needed, seek mediation or legal help.
From the Blog
Have questions about Shariah-compliant marriage guidance?
Contact Us