Answering Criticism of Polygamy Calmly
IMB Editorial Team · 21 November 2026 · about 4 min read
When someone criticises plural marriage, calling every question "Islamophobia" is wrong, and so is presenting real injustice as Islam's rule. First understand what the questioner is talking about. Then answer calmly, with sources. Where you are not sure, saying "I do not know" and sending them to a qualified scholar is an honest answer.
Understand the question first
Criticism comes from different places.
- A question about scripture: what does the Quran say and what does it mean?
- A question about law: what is its position in the country's law?
- A question about justice to women: are women harmed by it?
- Personal pain: someone may have seen injustice in their own family.
- A specific complaint of abuse: someone cheated or did not pay maintenance.
Answering without knowing which it is only fuels the argument. Sometimes a person does not want reasoning; they want someone to hear their pain.
Three steps of an answer
Step one: acknowledge the concern. You might say, "Neglect of maintenance or deception is truly harmful, and I agree." This shows the questioner you have not gone on the defensive.
Step two: give the whole of what the Quran says. Surah An-Nisa (4:3) contains the permission, but if injustice is feared it directs one wife. Surah An-Nisa (4:129) forbids inclining wholly to one and leaving the other suspended. State both the permission and the condition. Saying only one leaves half the picture.
Step three: name the legal layer separately. According to the official text of the law (whose current form a lawyer should verify), section 6 of the Muslim Family Laws Ordinance 1961 provides in Bangladesh a process of written Arbitration Council permission before another marriage during an existing one, and states specific consequences for marrying without it. Saying this shows that both Islam's teaching and the country's law speak of responsibility.
What not to say
Do not state numbers, history or statistics that you have not seen with their sources. Claims like "the West is wrong in this" or "so many percent in that country", spread without checking, break trust. Surah Al-Hujurat (49:12) keeps believers from suspicion and backbiting. Slandering a group or person goes against that instruction.
The etiquette of debate
Surah An-Nahl (16:125) teaches wisdom, good counsel and debate in the best manner. Calling the questioner "Western", "feminist" or "irreligious" does not strengthen your argument; it closes the door on discussion. The lesson of Surah Al-Ma'idah (5:8), that dislike must not lead away from justice, applies here too.
Some ways to answer honestly:
- "I am not sure about this; let me learn from a qualified scholar."
- Give the name of a verified source or the surah and verse number.
- Separate your own opinion from what scholars agree on.
- Do not turn a woman's private pain into material for a theoretical debate.
Speaking with someone in pain
If someone speaks angrily from their own family's experience, listening comes before reasoning. Say, "I am sorry for your pain." Then work out whether they want a solution or just want to be heard. If needed, point them to a mufti, a lawyer or a counsellor.
An example from real life
Online or at a family gathering someone says, "Islam gave a way to cheat women." One kind of answer: "You do not understand Islam." Another: "What worries you most: maintenance, justice or law? I will say what I know and ask a scholar about the rest." The second answer keeps a conversation going; the first stops it.
Common mistakes
Treating criticism as an attack; spreading numbers without checking the source; labelling the questioner; calling real injustice acceptable in the name of religion; and turning someone's pain into a weapon to win a debate.
When to ask a mufti or specialist
On hard Sharia questions, send people to a qualified mufti rather than answering yourself. You can send questions through /ask-mufti. For legal questions, take a Bangladeshi family lawyer's advice. For someone drowning in personal pain, an experienced counsellor may also be needed.
Frequently Asked Questions
How should I answer criticism of polygamy?
Acknowledge the concern first, then calmly give Surah An-Nisa 4:3 and 4:129 and the legal layer separately.
Is it right to call a critic Islamophobic?
No; understand the question first, since labels shut down the conversation.
What if I do not know the answer?
Saying 'I do not know' and referring to a qualified scholar is an honest answer.
Is it good to argue with statistics?
Do not quote numbers whose source you have not seen yourself.
From the Blog
Have questions about Shariah-compliant marriage guidance?
Contact Us